05/05/2009

FAT. Now there's a word ...

... that strikes fear into anyone who doesn't know the meaning of chaffing.

Speaking as someone who hasn't seen their feet since 1971, and who judges herself by her waist size, not the glory of her IQ or how obviously utterly fabulous she is, I looked upon making TV documentary Fix My Fat Head as my chance to sort out, once and for all, why I do what I do.

And that, simply put, is sometimes overeat for comfort and pleasure – though not all the time, so let's be clear about that from the start. Don't for a minute think that, as a big bird, I sit in the house stuffing chocolate, fried bread and beef burgers for breakfast. I don't. But I know, deep down, I have the capacity for turning my brand of indulgence up a notch.

I also have a wonky view of myself, my allure, my attractiveness and self worth. And I think that's all to do with the fact that I seem to have spent my life on countless diets, regardless of my personal achievements – and let's not forget that I'm a journalist, newspaper columnist, a published author, and all round (sic) nice guy. I self-medicate with Fruit 'n' Nut, and I've spent years wondering if I'd ever get to grips with myself, that authentic (thank you, Oprah) part of me that wakes up EVERY morning – and not just 1 in 77 – and screams, bugger it, you're great just the way you are. And that doesn't matter if you're a size eight or a 28.

Like every other woman I know, I've followed the dietary Holy Trinity in a bid to lose weight – calorie counting, Atkins and abject misery – but nothing has ever worked long term for me.

"Eat less, move more" is society's helpful mantra. But why can't people like me do it? As we all know, advice isn't like T-shirts – one size certainly doesn't fit all. So I came to the conclusion that the problem was surely all in my head. The bigger question, of course, was would I find something during filming which would help me move on and out of my big fat way?

The journey was certainly an interesting one, as I tried out an overeaters' support group, an extreme dieting class, Cognitive Behaviour Therapy sessions and a few goes on the chair with a hypnotist to the stars.

The latter was perhaps the most telling as she asked me if I'd ever been called Dumbo growing up. Dumbo! At first I thought she was referring to someone calling me "thick"; when the penny finally dropped on camera, I hope the disappointment on my face says it all. For the record, the film wasn't made by someone who needed to drop ONE dress size or tone up A BIT. When I started filming I was at least seven stones overweight and a size 24.

The difference between me and most women, though, is that I have never harboured ambitions to be a size 12.

I'm just a normal someone who'd like to fit into a size 18-20 dress and think, finally, that what I feel on the outside is doing what I'm capable of on the inside justice.

I was just fed up of feeling fat, of, in internet terms at least, being more niche market than marketable as a sexy, sassy, sorted, strong woman, of pretending to do up the laces on my zip-up shoes after a single flight of stairs.

My relationship with food and myself has always been complex, like the best kind of carbs. So this film was a chance to look at why that is, why I'm such a harsh critic, and why I reach for crusty bread and strawberry jam sandwiches at times of difficulty and joy.

I also wanted it to be funny and light-hearted, because that's how I am. At the same time, it needed to reflect my confusion, disappointment and sadness about this one area of my life that I can't seem to get a handle on. Sure I laugh during it… but my "issues" also bring me crashing to my knees.

So here I am then, literally waiting for a film of my life to start, and some very meaty questions still remain: Have I lost weight? Do I look in the mirror and feel satisfied? Did I learn enough to move on with a more healthy and balanced view of myself?

I'll leave you to be the judge of that tonight. (I'm far too busy thinking about what I’m going to have for dinner to possibly comment.)

13 comments:

MandiM said...

Probably, the worse thing about being big and female is the fact that so many folk immediately make up their minds about you based on the way you look. Society has somehow decided that the ideal women should is a petite doll-like creature that presents no visual threat or rivalry to the men around her.

It's bad enough being big - but try being big AND tall, and you're really out of 'what we should be like' territory.

All too often when first meet someone, I can almost see the thought bubble appear above their heads saying: "Well, she's got a nice smile, but she obviously lazy, greedy and undisciplined."

If they bothered to get to know me they would learn that, despite being a hulling size 18, I walk at least an hour every day, haven't been in touch with my deep frier for decades and exist mostly on fruit, veg and rice...

If they bothered to delve a little deeper, they might even find out that I have a wicked wit, a ready smile, and a pretty decent brain underneath all these layers.

Sadly, most don't bother to look more than skin-deep. But when it comes right down to it, that's their loss, not mine.

MandiM said...

Hope you don't mind but I've put your blog URL on my Twitter, so you might get a few more visitors.

If you're on Twitter, and you feel like connecting there, my ID is @Mandi112

And sadly no, we don't get BBC (or at least not current BBC) so if there is anywhere I can see the prog online......?

GailQB said...

Hi Hannah

Saw the programme last night & just wanted to say, I hear you. There are so many people out there whose experience parallels yours, me included !!
So thanks for speaking up and I hope you are glad you did.
Celebrating International No Diet Day today... and really tasting the freedom. Hope you are too.
G

Anonymous said...

Hi Hannah
I saw your prog last night and I thought you were so cool. You really moved me and I really get where you are coming from as I have very similar relationship with food.
I just wanted to say that you are so cool, funny and attractive, that's the overwhelming impression I was left with at the end of the prog.

Hannah Jones said...

Thank you all so much for those fab comments.... always good to get feedback and for people to "get it", if you know what I mean. Thanks again... Hannah

HospitalLabTech said...

Wow oh wow. I've jut been watching your programme on iplayer with my jaw wide open at how remarkably similar we are in our attitudes to food. Every word you said could have come from my lips!

I *completely* get it.

I'm so sorry for you that you are having these issues, but so pleased for me to realise that there is another soul out there who thinks like I do!

My current fad is the low-GI thing as my weight and carb-loaded diet has lead to polycystic ovaries and I'm on the brink of diabetes so I really must get past my demons.

Wishing you all the best in the battle...

Jess said...

Hi Hannah,

I just watched your documentary for the BBC and I felt compelled to write to you. I'm sure your story resonates with so many women. We so rarely get to see larger people on television beyond the 'headless fatties' in scare stories about the obesity crisis.

I was wondering if you are familliar with Health At Every Size (HAES), and the fat acceptance movement? A brilliant place to start is Kate Harding's Shapely Prose:

http://kateharding.net

Thanks for your thought-provoking work and congratulations on the success of your programme.

Anonymous said...

I loved the program, I bawled, laughed, and sat bolt upright at some points with lightbulbs popping around my head. Thanks so much. And, btw, you're gorgeous.

Unknown said...

I just watched your prog online, and i loved it! i had to find your blog coz i couldn get enuff. Your wit, ur insight...all faaaabulous darling. :-) But can I just say, for fear of bein ostracised for not bein fat enough, im a size 12, and i have issuse with food! I think , even the size zeros, have issues with food. every1 does!!! I connected with what you were sayin: I eat wen im bored, as a 'companion', wen im depressed etc etc. EVERY1 uses food as a crutch. and if it was soooooooo easy to loose weight, we'd all be a size zero! sigh. sorry, went off on a rant there. I just think, well, ur gorgeous, and funny and intelligent. Its sad, that as u say, bein fat, is the first, and sometimes the only thing people see in this society.

Ivor Lewis said...

Being fat is comparable to being the little flag in the middle of a tug of war rope. At one end pulling with all their might is the ‘it’s fab to be fat’ team, who demand you embrace your curves, offer you sexy underwear, and who wear big jewellery. Whereas at the other end hanging on for grim death, there is the ‘I don’t understand how she can let herself get so fat’ team, who stare just that little bit too long at your curves, say we don’t have a plus size department, and who wear….well pretty much anything they like.

This tug of war never seems to end (a bit like a cricket match) when one minute the fab to be fat team have found a grove and the flag lurches to wards their team and you find yourself skipping down the street arm in arm with Tracy Turnblad and Beth Ditto singing your heart out. But then someone in the fab to be fat team slips and the flag hurtles to the other side and suddenly you stop singing and you’re surrounded by slim folk who just give you a sideways glance up and down as they walk past, but never stop.

And so it goes on, but all I really want is for the flag to stay still and perfectly central (probably flogging the metaphor a little at this point); after all I’m not very good at skipping as I fear I would loose teeth and I don’t really want to be someone who could wear anything. I’d much rather just be allowed to be okay, to have some curves and wear them well and to be taken seriously.

Of course I want to loose weight and I know the simple equation but there is just too much pressure to choose which team I want to be on….. so I rebel and retreat into the nearest crisp packet until the next time the flag moves.

Lisa cowburn said...

Hannah.. first of can i just say thank you for your show... for the first time ever i finally realised im not the only one out there who thinks like that... iam a big girl... well very big... and for so many years i have dieted and as you put it " dived head long in to a vat of carbs" cause i felt like i was missiong out on something.

I dream of having a normal person relashionship with food instead of it being my every thought.. and i have found that dieting only makes that worse.. cause you still have to think about the food.

It is an addicition.. but unlike most its not something you can go cold turkey from... Like you i know what im meant to do, but i just cant do it.

I just started a new eating program from my doctors.. that i asked to join... and its about reprogramming the way yuo think about food.. but once again.. every time i fill out my food diary i feel guilty about eating normal things.

well good luck in the future.. and thanks again for making me feel a little lass alone in my fight with food.

lisa

Hannah Jones said...

My latest "thing" is a personal trainer. Haven't been going long, but I go and then don't worry - too much.... - about grub. News today is that I ran for 7 minutes. Seven fucking minutes! I came home and celebrated with chicken enchiladas. I may read that again.... slooooooooooowly.

Anonymous said...

Good Day!!! hanjonhanjon.blogspot.com is one of the most excellent resourceful websites of its kind. I enjoy reading it every day. hanjonhanjon.blogspot.com rocks!